DISQUS

Pop Critics: American Idol 2008 Results - Top 10 Announced - March 19

  • Mike · 1 year ago
    I think Carly was in the bottom because of that horrible rose shirt she wore the night before, my Gods that was awful :)

    I was totally praying she wasn't going home yet, because I couldn't IMAGINE a world where Kristy and Amanda stayed and Carly went home.
  • Jason · 1 year ago
    She deserved to go home for that blouse.
  • jina · 1 year ago
    I love you two talking about fashion on AI!

    One thing to add... this season could be strange going, because the contestants' styles are getting more and more diverse each season, which lends to different types of fan bases. And some of those fan bases aren't really Idol-voters, even if they are Idol-watchers. May be something to watch as the season progresses. Luckily for Archuleta, tweens vote!
  • patricia · 1 year ago
    Kristy Lee Cook is going to surprise all of you
  • nicky · 1 year ago
    Actually, all of the girls in the bottom 3 this week have made horrible fashion choices the entire season. Maybe the voters are all fashionistas now? heehee.

    nicky's last blog post..Red, Yellow, GREEN! Diaper Bags
  • Jason · 1 year ago
    @jina - We have many diverse talents. Fashion is just one.

    @patricia - I'm a Kristy Lee Cook fan. At least, I was. I'm pulling for her, but she hasn't been bringing much for me to cheer for lately.
  • Jeff · 1 year ago
    Kristy sucks and has a 0% chance of winning. Ramiele is in the same boat. In fact, having multiple females in the bottom three is going to be a common occurrence.

    That being said, I was more than happy to be wrong in thinking Amanda might last another week. I'm stoked she is gone.
  • Jason · 1 year ago
    @nicky - Maybe you're right.

    I loved what Syesha was wearing for the performance show. Who's with me, guys? You know you liked it.
  • Jeff · 1 year ago
    Syesha was looking hot. I always thought she was pretty, but with her hair down and that cleavage popping dress she was sportin. That was good stuff.
  • sinead · 1 year ago
    i love jason castro!!!!!!!!!!!!!11
  • rb · 1 year ago
    this season could be strange going, because the contestants’ styles are absulutely good. And, Kristy was looking hot. I always thought she was pretty.
  • Brandon · 1 year ago
    go rock and roll!!!!!!!!!!!!





    YEAH!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Brandon · 1 year ago
    my favorite people are brooke,david c, david a,and syesha :)
  • Brandon · 1 year ago
    were all sorry Brooke :(
  • Cheap Marc Jacobs Purses · 1 year ago
    I felt bad for Brooke. I really liked her. Oh well. Anyone know where she is now?