I thought Jason was boring and Brooke was good, not great. Memo to Idol contestants -just because you can use and instrument, doesn't mean you should. I think Jason and Brooke both do better when they can focus just on singing.
Top 3: Carly -love her, she rocks, Chikezie -was great last nite, and David Cook -another strong performance
Bottom 3: David Hernandez -horrible song choice, David Archuleta -forgot the words, sound horrible, if he wasn't cute as a puppy he'd be gone, Kristi Lee Cook -just not good dawg. Going home -Kristi Lee Cook, we hardly knew you.
See, I don't get the slam on instruments, because most singers once they get out there use some form of them in their act.
I love the piano, love the guitar...I think I like Jason because he's folk-sounding, and Brooke has a great little country twang to her voice.
Scotty Dub
· 1 year ago
It's not a slam on instruments, it's that these singer are under crazy pressure and adding an instrument means they have to focus on doing 2 things well instead of just 1. Jason and Brooke are good singers, but seem to fade a bit when they add the instrument. Their best performances are without IMO.
Yeah, I couldn't decide it "8 Days a Week" was being done too fast or too slow (sometimes both at the same time) but I could tell that it was wrong, wrong, wrong. I was horrified.
I was also surprised that Paula disagreed with Randy not once, but twice! And it's agreed that if Paula says it wasn't good, it was absolutely terrible. :)
Yeah, it was too fast. I still maintain that it wasn't that bad. Not great, but not the worst thing we've heard on Idol...not even this week.
thel
· 1 year ago
i think chikezie was just awesome. ramiele has so much potential and should just explore it.achuletta dissappointed me so much ,what was that?brook was good too there 's something attractive about her voice.syesha should just go all out and do something adventurous with her voice she's playing too safe for my liking.david cook definitely is in this competiton big time.amanda was not so good and i wonder if she can sing anyother type of song.kristy????????????
All Comments
David Archuletta...ugh man, remember the lyrics DAWG!
I agree with who you think is going home.
The country version of Eight Days A Week was simply awful. The judges were right on with that one.
I liked Michael Johns song, but was hoping he was going to perform While My Guitar Gently Weeps. Now that would have been a great choice for him.
Wasn't crazy about David Cook's song choice until he hit the chorus - wow.
Chikezie was incredible. Absolutely the best performance.
Steven's last blog post..Top 100 Movies: No. 69 - The 40-Year-Old Virgin (2005)
Top 3: Carly -love her, she rocks, Chikezie -was great last nite, and David Cook -another strong performance
Bottom 3: David Hernandez -horrible song choice, David Archuleta -forgot the words, sound horrible, if he wasn't cute as a puppy he'd be gone, Kristi Lee Cook -just not good dawg.
Going home -Kristi Lee Cook, we hardly knew you.
Scotty Dub's last blog post..Tech Skills vs Soft Skills
I love the piano, love the guitar...I think I like Jason because he's folk-sounding, and Brooke has a great little country twang to her voice.
Scotty Dub's last blog post..Tech Skills vs Soft Skills
But I still think you are a shining star, Jason!
I put her at #7 because...well, look at the people I put under her. I wasn't sure who of those was actually better...none as I decided.
nicky's last blog post..J.Crew Via Vittoria Jacket
My top 3 are: 1. Brooke, 2. David C., and 3. Michael Johns.
Jacuzzi didn't even crack my top 5 - I had him pegged at 6.
A girl is going home tonight - doesn't really matter which one - Kristy or Ramiele.
I felt sorry for Lennon & McCartney last night - way to butcher some classic songs American Idol...
The Trousered Ape's last blog post..American Idol (2008) - Week 4 - Top 3
I was also surprised that Paula disagreed with Randy not once, but twice! And it's agreed that if Paula says it wasn't good, it was absolutely terrible. :)
Robert's last blog post..The Complete Cat Care Guide Review
The Trousered Ape's last blog post..American Idol: You Pick the Songs - Week 1
ramiele has so much potential and should just explore it.achuletta dissappointed me so much ,what was that?brook was good too there 's something attractive about her voice.syesha should just go all out and do something adventurous with her voice she's playing too safe for my liking.david cook definitely is in this competiton big time.amanda was not so good and i wonder if she can sing anyother type of song.kristy????????????