Pop Critics: American Idol 2008 - Top 16 Announced
Mike
· 1 year ago
I liked Alaina Whitaker, so that's a bummer...she shouldn't have gone yet...
Jeff
· 1 year ago
No, Jason. You can only count those who you say will get cut. I had Alaina as a dark horse for getting cut too, but I said Kady would get cut. I was wrong, you were wrong, and America was wrong for not cutting Kady.
The point is to make a final decision and not say a bunch of maybe's and think that's good enough.
You can say you had called it in your post, but the cut decisions are what counts for us. Maybe we should have clarified the contest. It's okay to lose to me. It's been done many times before... LOL
Jeff
· 1 year ago
By the way, those four pictures of the cut contestants look pretty familiar.
Mike
· 1 year ago
Wow, the "friendly" competition is starting to get hostile...
Are you both 5-3 now?
daddyjason
· 1 year ago
Jeff, you bring up a good and valid point in that we didn't actually clarify any set of rules in this contest of ours... I did, however, say that I'm 4-4 according to YOU, and that you are 5-3, clearly allowing that you have the lead according to your rules (however, arbitrary they may be).
Oh, by the way, I did borrow those pictures from you. I'll return them early next week if that's cool...
Jeff
· 1 year ago
I know where you got the pictures, but you can keep them.
Arbitrary, please. You have the arbitrary rules. You pick two guys and two girls. Either they get eliminated or they don't. It's as simple as that.
daddyjason
· 1 year ago
Ah, but your rules mean that I'm losing...there's the rub...
Jeff
· 1 year ago
It's only one contestant off. You have to admit that Alexandrea was a great gut feeling on my part.
daddyjason
· 1 year ago
Lucky pick. If it had gone the way it should have, you'd be crying about how you made a dumb pick...
The Trousered Ape
· 1 year ago
It doesn't really matter much who goes right now - the majority of the people left are riff-raff. The top 5 or 6 should be pretty strong though, probably stronger than past seasons.
Jina
· 1 year ago
Ape said riff-raff... that makes me giggle.
Mike
· 1 year ago
The church we go to is called Lifechurch.tv, and we just found out tonight that Alaina went to our church but at the Oklahoma campus...
Wish they had let us all know, we may have been more inclined to vote!
The Trousered Ape
· 1 year ago
booo... c'mon Mike - that is not reason to vote for someone.
All Comments
The point is to make a final decision and not say a bunch of maybe's and think that's good enough.
You can say you had called it in your post, but the cut decisions are what counts for us. Maybe we should have clarified the contest. It's okay to lose to me. It's been done many times before... LOL
Are you both 5-3 now?
Oh, by the way, I did borrow those pictures from you. I'll return them early next week if that's cool...
Arbitrary, please. You have the arbitrary rules. You pick two guys and two girls. Either they get eliminated or they don't. It's as simple as that.
Wish they had let us all know, we may have been more inclined to vote!
The Trousered Ape's last blog post..Google