Pop Critics - Latest Comments in The Friday Question - American Idol

Re: The Friday Question - American Idol

Scotty Dub — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 15:47:25 -0000

I think I'm with Jina, I really don't care who wins, altho I'd add as long as it's not David A. We've seen with Daughtry that sometimes it's better to not win.

Scotty Dub's last blog post..Casual Dress Friday: the armpit sniff and other interview gaffes

Re: The Friday Question - American Idol

Cap'n Schwartz — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 12:26:46 -0000

LOL @ Nicky.... between you and Jina today, you guys are making me smile...

Re: The Friday Question - American Idol

nicky — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 12:23:04 -0000

David Archuletta is so cute, I want to pop off his head, super glue it onto a cabbage patch kid and carry around my own cutie pie doll everywhere I go.
BARF!
He will win b/c old ladies and preteen girls will be shown crying in the audience in about 3 weeks. He'll go on to have his own Nickelodeon show and brand of energy drinks. But like Jina said, I don't really care b/c the other truly great people should crack the top 5 and still have the chance to be successful.

nicky's last blog post..Poisonous flower.

Re: The Friday Question - American Idol

Rob O. — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 11:22:40 -0000

Oh dawg, could Randy Jackson be any more white? He (briefly) played bass for Journey & Whitney Houston. C'mon dawg! He tries entirely too hard to be far more hip than he'll ever quite be. Give Dorothy back the ruby slippers and suck it up!

Anybody else notice that nearly every time he criticizes a performer for being "pitchy," his own voice cracks while saying the word? Dawg. That's pitchy!

Re: The Friday Question - American Idol

Rob O. — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 11:18:47 -0000

"Bean" = David Cook. So named by me because of his bean-shaped noggin' that his atrocious haircut does nothing to disguise. Early on, I was convinced that he was way too cocky even despite his talent, but I've about decided that the swagger is just personality, not ego. But fer goodness sakes, somebody get the guy a hair stylist tho!

Jason has some heck of an ego, however. He's absolutely convinced of his own beauty. Very sad that his talents comes nowhere near compensating.

Re: The Friday Question - American Idol

Mike — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 11:15:06 -0000

Dawg :)

Re: The Friday Question - American Idol

jina — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 11:10:30 -0000

The strangest thing about this competition (and probably a nightmare to Idol producers) is that I don't care who wins anymore! Not to say that I want someone sucky to win, but overall, I think if you make it in the Top 5, you have just as good of a chance to do something with your newfound exposure.

But to play along, I think David Cook could win it all... Dawg, I mean he's got colors and textures, and doesn't sound like some ghastly cruise ship performer!

Re: The Friday Question - American Idol

Cap'n Schwartz — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 11:10:15 -0000

I agree with Ape, even though he didnt say anything yet =) young boy toy Archuletta will win, cause too many teeny-bopper girls and their crushes will call him to victory.
However, I would prefer out of all the contestants that Michael Johns win.. he looks like, acts like, he would be the best rock star out of any of them, hes got the gusto of a star in waiting!!

Re: The Friday Question - American Idol

Mike — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 10:39:25 -0000

Why don't I know who Bean refers to? :)

Re: The Friday Question - American Idol

Rob O. — Fri, 28 Mar 2008 09:57:21 -0000

Provided that the prepubescent girls don't overtake the vote and propel David Archuleta all the way up, I think "Bean" has it sewn up.

Michael & Carly will likely go on to do other stuff, a la Kelly Clarkson, but Jason & Brooke won't. I predict that David A. will find his way into a 4-piece boy band and go on theme park tours. He's just too saccharin-sweet to thrive in the real world.